I have seen it repeatedly, during jummah, after one of the congregational prayers, or during a special Islamic event, a young person approaches the microphone timidly and declares the testimony of faith. Under the guidance of an imam or other community leader, they repeat the Shahada, first in Arabic and then in English, “I bear witness that there is nothing worthy of worship except Allah, and I bear witness that Muhammad is His slave and final Messenger.” With these words, they are welcomed into the global Islamic community with shouts of “Takbir!” and thundering echoes of “Allahu akbar!” The congregation lines up to shake hands, hug, and exchange pleasantries with the new convert. However, when the fuss is over, the newcomer is often abandoned to learn his faith alone during one of the most challenging periods of his life.
According to the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding (ISPU), one in five American Muslims is a convert. Of those converts, 11 percent are between the ages of 18 and 24.1 There are even younger converts, but there is no data on their current numbers. In the best-case scenario, these youth have Muslim friends or a circle they can turn to for support, but realistically speaking, how much can they learn from other teens? If Islamic centers do not have adequate support programs for new worshippers, then they risk being part of those who reportedly leave Islam in the first two years after their conversion.
I was one of the fortunate young converts who remained steadfast during that delicate period. My journey began at 15, when I first learned about Islam, and culminated in my conversion at the age of 20, alhamdulillah. One of the key people who supported me early on was the mosque’s youth coordinator. He warned me that the next two years would be especially difficult, as Shaytan would work relentlessly to pull me away from the straight path. Thanks to his guidance and the support of Muslim friends and their families, I was better prepared to face those tests. A few years later, I began participating in dawah work to assist others who were exploring Islam. Fast forward to today, and I have spent the last two decades volunteering and working with the Islamic Circle of North America (ICNA) and WhyIslam. Throughout this time, I have noticed a recurring trend: The Muslim community is obsessed with conversion stories yet gives little attention to what happens afterward. How do converts continue their learning, adjust to a new lifestyle, and find their place within the Muslim community?
Now that I am a mother to teenagers, I have a new vantage point. I witness how they interact with their non-Muslim friends, some of whom are curious about Islam and occasionally attend mosque events. In fact, one of my son’s classmates recently embraced Islam. Seeing him at jummah and community functions fills me with joy, reminding me of the path I once walked. Drawing from my personal journey, academic research, and years of dawah experience, I have compiled a list of practical strategies and accessible resources to support young new Muslims in their transition. These tools can help families, mosques, and youth groups provide consistent mentorship, authentic friendship, and opportunities for spiritual and social growth.
Practical strategies to support new Muslim youth
-
Offer free and regular classes on the basics of Islam
New Muslims often need instruction on essential aspects of their new faith. Weekly classes covering topics such as Islamic etiquette, prayer, fasting, and manners can make a significant difference. To ensure accessibility, schedule these sessions after school hours and target the 14–25 age group. Having welcoming teachers and interactive formats can also enhance engagement and retention.
-
Establish support groups and social events
Social connection is crucial, especially for young people navigating a new religious identity. Create youth halaqas (study circles) or support groups specifically for new Muslims. Consider starting a group chat to keep them connected through their mobile devices and host regular gatherings like game nights, field trips, or dinners. These events allow young converts to ask questions, share their experiences, and feel a sense of belonging.
-
Provide opportunities for recreation and community building
Youth need safe, welcoming environments where they can relax and build friendships. Mosques and community centers should invest in designated youth spaces that include indoor and outdoor sports facilities (basketball, soccer, volleyball, etc.), game rooms, cafés, or comfortable lounges. These recreational outlets encourage community bonding and help young people stay connected to the mosque.
-
Implement an open-door policy with religious leaders and mentors
Every young Muslim, especially a new convert, needs access to trustworthy guidance. Islamic centers should consider employing youth coordinators or chaplains, ideally one for boys and another for girls. Ideally, imams and staff must be approachable and trained in youth development, mentorship, and spiritual counseling. This availability helps address personal challenges before they escalate and reinforces trust in religious leadership, which has waned in recent years.
-
Educate the community on how to welcome and support converts
While new Muslims are adjusting to a different way of life, the broader community also needs guidance on how to support them. Hosting convert-awareness workshops can teach congregants proper ways to interact with newcomers with empathy, patience, and kindness, emulating the example of the Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, who treated everyone with dignity.
-
Increase access to Islamic education through scholarships and financial aid
Financial barriers often prevent convert families from accessing Islamic education. ISPU reported, “Where convert Muslims and born Muslim families with school-aged children differ is in the proportion who send their kids to Islamic schools (4 percent of converts vs. 28 percent of born Muslims). This may reflect economic obstacles among converts to access private Islamic schools, underscoring the need for more financial aid offerings1.” Offering access to Islamic education, including scholarships and financial aid opportunities for new Muslim youth and their families, will help address this disparity.
If the takbir we shout when a young person embraces Islam is truly sincere, then our responsibility must extend beyond a warm welcome on the day of their conversion. Celebrating their entry into the faith is not enough; we must create the conditions for their growth, security, and success. This means offering them consistent support, inclusive spaces, and the tools they need to navigate life as confident Muslims. The new Muslim youth of today are not just our brothers and sisters, they are the future leaders of our communities and the parents of generations to come. What are we doing to prepare them for that sacred trust?
